Table 1

Summary of study characteristics.

Author (s)YearStudy locationGenderStages of developmentModalityType of researchInstrumentsSoftwareSocial influencesStudy quality
Wyllerman et al.2002NSM/FIIndividualQuantitativeQuestionnairesNSF/CB
Wuerth, Lee & Alfermann2004GermanyM/FS/SP/IIndividual CollectiveQuantitativeQuestionnairesNSFA
Wolfenden & Holt2005EnglandM/FSPIndividualQualitativeSemi-structured interviewsNSF/CA
Jowett & Timson-Katchis2005Republic of CyprusFIIndividualQualitativeSemi-structured interviewsNSF/CA
Ullrich-French & Smith2006USAM/FS/SPCollectiveQuantitativeQuestionnairesNSF/TA
Schinke et al.2006CanadaM/FS/SP/IIndividual CollectiveQualitativeSemi-structured interviewsNSFB
Mccarthy & Jones2007EnglandM/FSIndividual CollectiveQualitativeFocus groups / semi-structured interviewsNSF/C/TA
Jowett2008EnglandFS/SP/IIndividualQualitativeSemi-structured interviewsNSF/CA
Ullrich-French & Smith2009USAM/FS/SPCollectiveQuantitativeQuestionnairesNSF/TA
Keegan et al.2009NSM/FSIndividual CollectiveQualitativeInterviews – focus groupNVIVOF/C/TA
Keegan et al.2010NSM/FS/SP/IIndividual CollectiveQualitativeFocus groups / semi-structured interviewsNVIVOF/C/TA
Bhalla & Weiss2010CanadaFSP/IIndividual CollectiveQualitativeSemi-structured interviewsNSFA
Fry & Gano-Overway2010NSM/FS/SP/ICollectiveQuantitativeQuestionnairesNSC/TA
Jowett & Cramer2010NSM/FSP/IIndividualQuantitativeQuestionnairesNSCA
Lauer et al.2010NSM/FIIndividualQualitativeSemi-structured interviewsNSFA
Taylor & Bruner2012EnglandMS/SP/ICollectiveQuantitativeQuestionnairesEQSCB
Siekańska2012NSM/FIIndividual CollectiveQuantitativeQuestionnairesNSFB
Dionigi, Fraser-Thomas
& Logan
2012CanadaM/FIIndividual CollectiveQualitativeSemi-structured interviewsNSFA
Nunomura & Oliveira2013BrazilM/FSP/IIndividualQualitativeSemi-structured interviewsNSFB
Rottensteiner et al.2013FinlandM/FSP/ICollectiveQuantitativeQuestionnairesSPSSCA
Atkins et al.2013USAFSPIndividual CollectiveQuantitativeQuestionnairesEQSFA
Kubayi et al.2014South AfricaM/FINSQuantitativeQuestionnairesSPSSF/TB
Santi et al.2014NSM/FIIndividualQuantitativeQuestionnairesSPSS/AMOST/CA
Amado et al.2015SpainM/FS/SP/IIndividual CollectiveQuantitativeQuestionnairesSPSSFA
Marsh et al.2015USAM/FS/SP/IIndividual CollectiveQuantitative – qualitativeInterviews / questionnairesSPSSF/CB
Kang, Jeon & Kwon2015KoreaM/FS/SP/INSQuantitativeQuestionnairesPASWFA
Cranmer & Sollitto2015NSM/FIIndividual CollectiveQuantitativeQuestionnairesNSCA
MacPherson, Kerr & Stirling2016NSFS/SP/IIndividual CollectiveQualitativeSemi-structured interviews / photo-elicitationNSTA
Maniam2017AustraliaM/FIIndividual CollectiveQualitativeSemi-structured interviewsNVIVOFB
Danioni, Barni & Rosnati2017ItalyM/FSP/ICollectiveQuantitativeQuestionnairesNSFA
Folle et al.2018BrazilFS/SP/ICollectiveQualitativeSemi-structured interviewsNVIVOFA
Note. Stages of development (defined based on Côté, Baker & Albernethy, 2003); S: Sampling (up to 12 years); SP: Specialization (13 to 15 years); I: Investment (over 16 years); M: Male; F: Female; NS: Not specified; F: Family; C: Coaches; T: Teammates; A: High quality, B: Moderate quality.